See Alike in...

Alike App

Browser

IndigoBro

541d

My mother does not agree with my gender transition and she wants me to “go back” to being a girl/woman. One day she argues that men are society’s scourge, the cause of our world’s problems. Becoming a man is a terrible idea, I’ll just become stupider. The next day she argues that men have it so easy, who wouldn’t want to become a man. Then, how can I call myself a feminist if I think I have to transition into a man to live my masculine gender roles? Transitioning is just vanity. Who cares how people see you? Etc. I’m not saying her words don’t have any merit but the way that they flip between viewpoints confuses me about what she actually believes and what she’s just saying to attack me because she is threatened by the loss of her daughter. I wish we could actually have these nuanced conversations about gender instead of it all being so personal and weaponized. I never know what to say.

Top reply
    • AnimalBoy

      525d

      that can be more difficult since everyone is different. I think most importantly try to avoid questioning your stubbornness, you aren't wrong in this situation she is and she's the one allowing her refusal to listen to you and let go harmful stereotypes to harm your relationship so it's most definitely not on you to back down even if you should try to be as respectful as possible while trying to hash out miscommunication. While her perspective on this is an understandable one it's also a misinformed and sexist argument that attempts to strip you, and a lot of others, of bodily autonomy in the end. Usually when two people in an argument are both feeling attacked it helps to defuse the situation by making sure everyone is put on the same level and no one is making blanket or accusatory statements about the other person's part in the situation. (I.e instead of saying "your position is sexist and leaving room for excuses for men" or "you're hurting me by not listening" use I statements like "I find that reasoning that I can't become a good person because I am a man is the same reasoning that misogynistic men use to never get better as people." Or "I feel hurt and ignored because I cannot be myself.") As well as making sure she feels that she's being heard, make sure she knows that you understand where she's coming from but make a point to mention that you need her to understand your perspective and why it hurts you. You can also try to get her some informational print outs for the families of trans people from online if you think that could help. It also might help when shes talking about how its "easy" to be a man to point out that trans men are specifically targeted and oppressed by cis men (and women) specifically because they are men but in the "wrong" way so we also don't even really gain much privilege unless we spend our whole lives dedicated to living in stealth, which is frequently difficult and stressful. I don't know your mom so I don't know what will and won't work, and you could need some kind of 3rd party mediation like a counselor. But I hope she listens to you sooner rather than later, it's a shame she's putting so much strain on your relationship with her.

    • AnimalBoy

      525d

      that can be more difficult since everyone is different. I think most importantly try to avoid questioning your stubbornness, you aren't wrong in this situation she is and she's the one allowing her refusal to listen to you and let go harmful stereotypes to harm your relationship so it's most definitely not on you to back down even if you should try to be as respectful as possible while trying to hash out miscommunication. While her perspective on this is an understandable one it's also a misinformed and sexist argument that attempts to strip you, and a lot of others, of bodily autonomy in the end. Usually when two people in an argument are both feeling attacked it helps to defuse the situation by making sure everyone is put on the same level and no one is making blanket or accusatory statements about the other person's part in the situation. (I.e instead of saying "your position is sexist and leaving room for excuses for men" or "you're hurting me by not listening" use I statements like "I find that reasoning that I can't become a good person because I am a man is the same reasoning that misogynistic men use to never get better as people." Or "I feel hurt and ignored because I cannot be myself.") As well as making sure she feels that she's being heard, make sure she knows that you understand where she's coming from but make a point to mention that you need her to understand your perspective and why it hurts you. You can also try to get her some informational print outs for the families of trans people from online if you think that could help. It also might help when shes talking about how its "easy" to be a man to point out that trans men are specifically targeted and oppressed by cis men (and women) specifically because they are men but in the "wrong" way so we also don't even really gain much privilege unless we spend our whole lives dedicated to living in stealth, which is frequently difficult and stressful. I don't know your mom so I don't know what will and won't work, and you could need some kind of 3rd party mediation like a counselor. But I hope she listens to you sooner rather than later, it's a shame she's putting so much strain on your relationship with her.

    • AnimalBoy

      526d

      I mean these statements dont actually have any merit, you are not going to become stupid or worse because you're trans and a man. You're still you, you're not actually dead, and your beliefs on equal rights don't change because of that. What you're doing by transitioning is adding another feminist guy to the world, another guy who has some understanding of what women go through. This gives you a chance to add one more compassionate guy, one more guy who listens, one more guy who stands up for what is right, another guy to outnumber the assholes. All the while being who you actually are. How could that not be a good thing? This is just the same narrow minded bioessentialism that tells men they are better and women they are worse, or that tells women all men are terrible and men that all women think they're monsters. Blanket statements are never good it just gives them an excuse to continue the behavior because "men are just like that".

      • IndigoBro

        525d

        @AnimalBoy that’s how I feel!!! I sound like a broken record in front of her, until eventually I question my stubbornness and try to listen hoping she will return the favor. I always come out of the conversation so demoralized and at a loss for words. Im starting to think the root issue here is communication more than anything. How do you talk about these things when both parties feel personally attacked?

        • AnimalBoy

          525d

          @IndigoBro sorry I meant to tag you in my reply lol

    • R4in3b0w

      534d

      Wouldn't she want you to have it easier out here as a man? And being in that position of privilege gives you opportunities to help other men understand and to perhaps be better people in the feminist movement. There are also plenty of resources for parents of transgender children to help them understand. Just keep being who you are. Your mother loves you and she'll eventually have to accept you to continue to be in your life. It gets easier, trust me. <3

    • bunbunii

      534d

      Hey! Your mother sounds kinda like a TERF!!! I would honestly show her some articles as well as talk to her a bit about what that means and how, even though she’s a feminist, her opinions are not that of feminist views and is language used to exclude and gatekeep people from the feminist movement. I could totally show u some vids/links that could explain this much better than me. Feel free to DM!

    • Mrmrs

      535d

      Hey, don't listen to her. Be who you want to be. Sometimes our parents fail to understand all the changes that have been made in the definitions of sex and gender in recent years. It's not that there are more people who are on the gender spectrum, it's just that today everything is more open to talk about it. You need to continue your process and understand what you want to be, and everything around is just background noise. I support you.

      10

      • IndigoBro

        534d

        @Mrmrs Thanks for your support

☝ This content is generated by our users and it is not a substitute for professional medical advice. Please consult with your physician before making any medical decision

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Want to chat or share? Download the Alike app now and get complete access to Alike.health's unique features.

Find people who are
experiencing a similar
medical reality

100% Free
100%
Free

Download Alike for the full experience

JOIN

View All

Bupropion

night sweats

paranoid

Valium

sertraline

palpitations

Anxiety (Including GAD)

Depression

palpitations

Depression

Valium

Bupropion